LEGGI
BENI IN PERICOLO
INTERVENTI E RECENSIONI
RASSEGNA STAMPA
COMUNICATI DELLE ASSOCIAZIONI
EVENTI
BIBLIOGRAFIA
STORIA e FORMAZIONE del CODICE DEI BENI CULTURALI E DEL PAESAGGIO
LINK
CHI SIAMO: REDAZIONE DI PATRIMONIOSOS
BACHECA DELLE TESI
per ricevere aggiornamenti sul sito inserisci il tuo indirizzo e-mail
patrimonio sos
in difesa dei beni culturali e ambientali

stampa Versione stampabile

PITTSFELD - Still time for museum to avert a tragedy
Linda Kaye-Moses
Posted Friday, September 29, 2017 2:09 pm




PITTSFIELD — There is a question that is being asked today in The Berkshires; what is it that we value in our county? Answering that question, as someone who has made this county home for over 45 years, is easy, and is based on the reason for having moved here initially.

The Berkshires are beautiful in so many ways; abundant and luxuriant forests, walking trails, lakes, clean air and a rural ambience, coupled with numerous possibilities for more cosmopolitan experiences. But while that is accurate, it is incomplete.

What is missing from that description is the range of cultural experiences available in our county, including a remarkable number of museums for an area the size our our county and for what each of those institutions offers.

Community ignored

Which brings me to the point of this commentary. We, who treasure the museums, have been excluded from a discussion and subsequent decision to substantially and radically change the content and, indeed, the very nature of one of our most treasured museums, a museum that by its iconic name, Berkshire Museum, represents and holds in trust for us (or should), a collection that was donated for the praiseworthy and sole purpose of offering the people of Berkshire County the opportunity to expand their horizons through exposure to a superb art collection and an eclectic choice of anthropological and natural history objects.

The current director and board seem to have discounted the true value of the museum's collection, and by doing so have demonstrated a limited, or even a complete lack of, awareness of the devotion of the community to that collection. The decision to deaccession the most important objects in its collection disregarded the benefits derived from exposure to the very best and most appreciated of its art pieces.

Salvatore Settis, an art historian and the author of "If Venice Dies," in an interview for National Geographic (Oct. 16, 2016), in speaking of Venice (much of which can easily and generically be applied to The Shires) states, "the most dreadful danger for a city now is loss of memory. By loss of memory, I mean not forgetting that we exist, but who we are."

If the board wants a digitized museum it should build one elsewhere in the county. Settis describe a project which was proposed for Venice, that would create a theme park about Venice on one of the islands of its lagoon. He says, " Venice is able to tell its own history. We have no need to create a fake Doge's Palace in order to tell the history of Venice. We have the real Doge's Palace!"— just as we have the historically grounded and beloved Berkshire Museum.

He speaks of the beauty of the city as not just the aesthetics, but the harmony of its architecture within its environment, and the necessity of preserving that for future generations. Venice's existence, of course, is threatened by flooding. The threat to the existence of the museum is the unwillingness of the director and the board to reconsider the decision to "monetize" the art and de-construct the building itself.

Once 40 of the museum's most precious art pieces have been auctioned they will disappear into private collections, removed from public purview, never to be seen again by the population for whom it was originally intended, and given in trust to our Berkshire community. It may not be clear to those who have made this decision, but the Berkshire community feels ownership of this art, through the course of many generations of adults and children who have viewed it. The experience of being present with art that could only be seen at the Berkshire Museum and nowhere else, conveyed that sense of ownership.

This art work has become as comfortable as a well-worn sweater, welcomed on a cheerless winter day; and at the same time, remaining exhilarating, infusing the community of artists and other art-lovers with the warmth of inspiration.

The building itself is solidly and beautifully satisfying the eye with its archaic, though not outworn architectural style. It is a symbol of times when the thought of a structure was as important as the structure itself and what it would contain. This structure absorbed that importance grandly and with grace.

We have seen the disappearance of many such structures over the course of many decades, disappearances recommended as financially expedient. The loss of these is a canyon lined with regret, from which it is impossible to recover. They are gone forever. To add the museum and its unique architecture to this sad list would be tragic.

Take a step back

Unfortunately, despite attempts to accomplish this, there has been no public forum on these issues, and the museum has, so far, made no effort to initiate such an event. The museum, as a private trust, does not have to acknowledge the need for a forum and cannot be compelled to participate in one, and the community, or any coalition within the community, cannot insist.

If, however, it becomes evident that the museum has violated its responsibility to maintain the museum and its art for the public, it then becomes incumbent on any in the community to oppose and protest the sale of the art and the intended deconstruction of this venerable and valued institution.

It is past time for the museum board to take a step back, review its alternatives with a renewed perspective, in concert with a concerned community. I encourage the board to re-examine the extent of the loss of the art and the magnitude of the alteration of the institution that the plan in process would create. It is now time to become the creative organization that the museum must be in order to enable future generations to share the delights of this grand old museum.

Linda Kaye-Moses is an occasional Eagle contributor.

http://www.berkshireeagle.com/stories/linda-kaye-moses-still-time-for-museum-to-avert-a-tragedy,520686


news

08-12-2017
Rassegna Stampa aggiornata al giorno 08 DICEMBRE 2017

06-12-2017
Premio Silvia Dell'Orso 2017

03-12-2017
Novità editoriale - La struttura del paesaggio. Una sperimentazione multidisciplinare per il Piano della Toscana

22-11-2017
Fotografie libere. Lettera di utenti dell'ACS di Palermo al Ministro Franceschini

22-11-2017
COMUNICATO di Cunsta, della Società italiana di Storia della Critica dell'Arte e della Consulta di Topografia Antica sulla Biblioteca di Palazzo Venezia

20-11-2017
Intervento di Enzo Borsellino sulla mostra di Bernini

13-11-2017
Maestri: Emiliani ricorda Edoardo Detti

01-11-2017
Nella sezione Interventi e recensioni un nuovo intervento di Vittorio Emiliani sulla legge sfasciaparchi

01-11-2017
A un anno dal terremoto, dossier di Emergenza Cultura

29-10-2017
Petizione per salvare il Museo d'Arte Orientale dalla chiusura

20-10-2017
Crollo Santa Croce, l'esperto:INTERVISTA - "Da anni chiediamo fondi per consolidare pietre, inascoltati"

20-10-2017
Bonsanti sul passaggio di Schmidt da Firenze a Vienna

16-10-2017
MANOVRA, FRANCESCHINI: PIÙ RISORSE PER LA CULTURA E NUOVE ASSUNZIONI DI PROFESSIONISTI DEI BENI CULTURALI

24-09-2017
Marche. Le mostre e la rovina delle montagne

07-09-2017
Ascoli Satriano, a fuoco la copertura di Villa Faragola: la reazione di Giuliano Volpe

30-08-2017
Settis sui servizi aggiuntivi nei musei

29-08-2017
Carla Di Francesco il nuovo Segretario Generale - MIBACT

25-08-2017
Fotografie libere per i beni culturali: nel dettaglio le novit apportate dalla nuova norma

21-08-2017
Appello di sessanta storici dell'arte del MiBACT per la messa in sicurezza e la salvaguardia del patrimonio monumentale degli Appennini devastato dagli eventi sismici del 2016

19-08-2017
Dal 29 agosto foto libere in archivi e biblioteche

19-08-2017
Cosenza, brucia casa nel centro storico: tre persone muoiono intrappolate. Distrutte decine di opere d'arte

12-08-2017
Antonio Lampis, nuovo direttore generale dei musei del MiBACT

06-08-2017
L'appello al Presidente Mattarella: i beni culturali non sono commerciali. Come aderire

04-08-2017
Istat: mappa rischi naturali in Italia

03-08-2017
APPELLO - COSA SI NASCONDE NELLA LEGGE ANNUALE PER IL MERCATO E LA CONCORRENZA

31-07-2017
Su eddyburg intervento di Maria Pia Guermandi sulle sentenze del Consiglio di Stato e su Bagnoli- Stadio di Roma

31-07-2017
Comunicato EC Il Colosseo senza tutela: sulle recenti sentenze del Consiglio di Stato

30-07-2017
Dal blog di Giuliano Volpe: alcuni interventi recenti

27-07-2017
MiBACT, presto protocollo di collaborazione con le citt darte per gestione flussi turistici

26-07-2017
Franceschini in audizione alla Commissione Cultura del Senato

Archivio news