LEGGI
BENI IN PERICOLO
INTERVENTI E RECENSIONI
RASSEGNA STAMPA
COMUNICATI DELLE ASSOCIAZIONI
EVENTI
BIBLIOGRAFIA
STORIA e FORMAZIONE del CODICE DEI BENI CULTURALI E DEL PAESAGGIO
LINK
CHI SIAMO: REDAZIONE DI PATRIMONIOSOS
BACHECA DELLE TESI
per ricevere aggiornamenti sul sito inserisci il tuo indirizzo e-mail
patrimonio sos
in difesa dei beni culturali e ambientali

stampa Versione stampabile

Terror victims cannot seize Iranian antiquities, US Supreme Court rules
Martha Lufkin
22nd February 2018 23:20 GMT


A 2008 amendment to the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act does not open a foreign nation's assets to claimants, the justices unanimously decided


The US Supreme Court has unanimously ruled that the victims of a terrorist bombing sponsored by Iran cannot seize a collection of Persian antiquities at a Chicago museum as payment for their damages. The clay tablets and artefacts, loaned by Iran in 1937 to the University of Chicago and known as the Persepolis Collection, are immune from seizure as the property of a foreign state, the court said. In a victory for the museum, the objects will therefore remain at the Oriental Institute.

The victims, Jenny Rubin and others, won a $71 million court judgment in 2003 against Iran as a sponsor of Hamas, for damages they suffered from a 1997 triple suicide bombing in Jerusalem. Having lost every other attempt to seize assets owned by Iran to make good on the judgment, they claimed the Persepolis artefacts, invoking a section of the US Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act (FSIA) that allows victims to seize the assets of a foreign nation in terrorism cases.

Generally, the FSIA bars the seizure of a foreign nations assets unless the assets have been used in a commercial activity in the US. But the victims claimed that a 2008 amendment to the law removed the commercial activity test in cases like theirs. In a brief, 8-0 decision on 21 February that leaves no room for doubt, the court disagreed. The decision cuts off any appeal for Rubin, in her more than 20-year quest to make Iran pay. Justice Elena Kagan did not take part in the consideration or decision.

The Courts decision, written by Justice Sonia Sotomayor, said that Congress had enacted the FSIA to codify the balance between respecting the immunity historically afforded to foreign sovereigns and holding them accountable. But in a close textual analysis, the court concluded that when Congress wants to remove a foreign nations immunity from lawsuit, it does so explicitly. Such was not the case with the 2008 amendment, which lacks the unambiguous phrasing that Congress uses to deny immunity. The amendment, the Court said, was instead aimed at clearly commercial assets, such as those owned by a state-owned telecommunications agency.

Lawyers for the US government had argued against allowing the antiquities to be seized. The property at issue here consists of ancient Persian artifacts, documenting a unique aspect of Irans cultural heritage, that were lent to a US institution in the 1930s for academic study, the US government brief said. Execution against such unique cultural artifacts could cause affront and reciprocity problems.

Asher Perlin, the victims lawyer, told The Art Newspaper that the terrorist attack had shattered the lives of his clients. Disagreeing with the Court, he said that the 2008 amendment was one of repeated efforts by Congress to expand the remedies of American terrorism victims against nations that sponsor such acts.

Perlin said that the Court's decision requires plaintiffs to prove that property to be seized has been used for commercial activity in the US, adding that with Iran, that is a near impossibility because of existing sanctions against the country. This case presented a rare opportunity to hold Iran's feet to the fire and compel it to pay a US judgment. We regret that the Court let that opportunity slip away.

A conflicting decision by the federal appeals court in California in a case with similar facts had said that under the 2008 amendment, Irans assets could be seized even if the commercial activity test could not be met. The Supreme Court decision thus comes as a boon to Iran, which owes more than $47 billion to US victims of terrorist attacks based on earlier judgements.

https://www.theartnewspaper.com/news/terror-victims-cannot-seize-iranian-antiquities-us-supreme-court-rules


news

17-08-2018
Rassegna Stampa aggiornata al giorno 17 agosto 2018

08-08-2018
Comitato per la Bellezza. Altro palazzone di 6 piani in piena riserva naturale del Litorale romano

24-07-2018
Da Emergenza Cultura: San Candido (BZ), uno sfregio che si poteva e doveva evitare

21-07-2018
Inchiesta de "L'Espresso" di Francesca Sironi: Il ministro Alberto Bonisoli e la scuola offshore

20-07-2018
Associazione Nazionale Archeologi. MIBAC: il titolo non è unopinione!

08-07-2018
Su Eddyburgh un intervento di Maria Pia Guermandi sull'Appia Antica

13-06-2018
Disponibile la relazione di Giuliano Volpe sull'attività del Consiglio Superiore

12-06-2018
Lettera aperta al Sig. Ministro dei Beni Culturali dott. Alberto Bonisoli: Per un futuro all'archeologia italiana

04-06-2018
Dalla rete: sul nuovo governo e sul nuovo ministro dei Beni culturali

19-05-2018
Sul contratto M5S - Lega vi segnaliamo...

17-05-2018
Cultura e Turismo: due punti della bozza Di Maio - Salvini

15-05-2018
Sulla Santa Bibiana di Bernini: intervento di Enzo Borsellino

13-05-2018
Premio Francovich 2018 per il miglior museo/parco archeologico relativo al periodo medievale

04-05-2018
Nella sezione "Interventi e recensioni" abbiamo pubblicato un contributo di Franco Pedrotti sul depuratore della piana di Pescasseroli: una sconfitta del protezionismo italiano

01-05-2018
Archistorie: rassegna di films sull'architettura dell'Associazione Silvia Dell'Orso

30-04-2018
Nella sezione "Interventi e recensioni", abbiamo pubblicato un contributo di Vittorio Emiliani: Appena 11 giardinieri per Villa Borghese. Ma l'erba "privata" non è meglio

26-04-2018
Roma. Il nuovo prato di piazza di Spagna non regge, il concorso ippico migra al Galoppatoio

21-04-2018
Anna Somers Cocks lascia The Art Newspaper. Intervista su "Il Giornale dell'Arte"

04-04-2018
VIII edizione del Premio Silvia Dell'Orso: il bando (scadenza 30/9/2018)

29-03-2018
Comitato per la Bellezza: A Palazzo Nardini chiedono già affitti altissimi ai negozi

25-03-2018
Lettera aperta di Archeologi Pubblico Impiego - MiBACT ai Soprintendenti ABAP

25-03-2018
A Foggia dal 5 aprile rassegna Dialoghi di Archeologia

23-03-2018
Comitato per la Bellezza e Osservatorio Roma: Tre richieste fondamentali per salvare Villa Borghese e Piazza di Siena

17-03-2018
Comunicato ANAI sul tema delle riproduzioni fotografiche libere

16-03-2018
Podcast episode 23: The death of Venice?

14-03-2018
SETTIS ed EMILIANI: Le ruspe su alcuni villini di Roma

20-02-2018
Documento del Coordinamento delle Società Storiche a proposito della libera riproduzione in archivi e biblioteche

14-02-2018
Consulta Universitaria Nazionale per la Storia dell'Arte e la Società Italiana di Storia della Critica d'Arte manifestano la loro piena solidarietà a Christian Greco

14-02-2018
NOTA DEL COMITATO SCIENTIFICO DEL MUSEO EGIZIO

09-02-2018
Italia '900. Settima edizione di Visioni d'Arte organizzata dall'Associazione Culturale Silvia Dell'Orso

Archivio news