LEGGI
BENI IN PERICOLO
INTERVENTI E RECENSIONI
RASSEGNA STAMPA
COMUNICATI DELLE ASSOCIAZIONI
EVENTI
BIBLIOGRAFIA
STORIA e FORMAZIONE del CODICE DEI BENI CULTURALI E DEL PAESAGGIO
LINK
CHI SIAMO: REDAZIONE DI PATRIMONIOSOS
BACHECA DELLE TESI
per ricevere aggiornamenti sul sito inserisci il tuo indirizzo e-mail
patrimonio sos
in difesa dei beni culturali e ambientali

stampa Versione stampabile

Museums have a duty to be political
Jillian Steinhauer
20th March 2018 THe Art Newspaper


Activist curators and directors can make truly democratic spaces, but they need brave boards to support them

The former director of the Queens Museum in New York, Laura Raicovich, was celebrated for her political outspokenness. At Queens Museum, the Director Is as Political as the Art read the headline of a New York Times profile last October. Less than four months later, Raicovich abruptly announced her resignation. There are so many big things that art and culture have to contend with that are so wrong in the world, she told the New York Times. I just felt that my vision and that of the board werent in enough alignment to get that done.

Raicovich presented the decision to leave as her own; the Queens Museum board later claimed that it forced her, after investigating her handling of an Israel-sponsored event. Either way, it seems clear that the board did not fully support her activism, including her closure of the museum on Donald Trumps inauguration day, in step with calls for an art strike by prominent artists and critics, to hold a free protest sign-making event instead.

Raicovich strove to make the Queens Museum a truly progressive, community-orientated space. That is why her departure after only three years is worrisome. It represents the divide between those who think museums should refrain from being political and those who know that, from their foundation, they always have been.

Many of the Wests most beloved art museums began as private collectionsa way for royal and rich families and institutions to represent their good taste, wealth and power. The Uffizi in Florence, in its first form, was a private gallery established in 1581 to display the collection of the Medici family. Anna Maria Luisa de Medici bequeathed most of their treasures to the Tuscan state 162 years later, calling them an inalienable public good.

Natural history collections were more idiosyncratic, but similarly served as a showcase for their owners sophistication. Cabinets of curiosities presented natural specimens alongside man-made objects in an attempt to classify the world. This was inextricable from the ideology of colonialism, which placed Western society at the pinnacle of civilisation and viewed other lands, peoples and cultures as inferior, and hence exploitable.

Our present museums grew out of this privileged milieu. Largely white, wealthy people chose which objects to include, and continue to do so today as board and staff members. Recent surveys by New Yorks Department of Cultural Affairs and the New York Times found that the employees and trustees of the citys major arts institutions are overwhelmingly white. There is a reason why many people of colour still feel unwelcome in museums. It relates to the reason why museums so often display items from certain culturesincluding Native American and African onesas historical or ethnographic objects, rather than as works of art.

A recent grassroots T-shirt campaign summed it up: Museums are not neutral. As Raicovich herself tweeted last autumn: Neutrality is a fiction. Claiming not to take a position is actually a way of taking oneit means supporting the status quo. At a time when the status quo in the US is government-sanctioned racism and xenophobia, it is all the more urgent that museums acknowledge their political histories and adopt stances on contemporary issues.

There is no single right way to do this. Days after President Trump signed the travel ban last year, affecting people from mostly Muslim countries, curators at the Museum of Modern Art (MoMA) installed works by artists from some of the targeted countries in their galleries. It was an understated yet potent gesture of solidarity.

Far more brash was the offer by the Guggenheim Museums chief curator, Nancy Spector, to lend the White House Maurizio Cattelans 18-carat-gold functioning toilet, America. Some have argued that Spectors move was crass or alienating, but I found it brilliantly subversive. Like the MoMA curators, she used the art she had at hand as a means of protest. And why not? Trump has already made his disdain for culture clear in multiple attempts to eliminate the National Endowment for the Arts, most recently in the 2019 budget.

They did not start as such, but museums today are a public good. To foster education and exchange, they need to welcome all kinds of people, not just the rich and powerful. Truly democratic spaces are not made by remaining neutral; creating them requires recalibrating the balance of power. Many museum workers have already begun this through socially conscious exhibitions and community outreach. However, as noted by more than 200 arts professionals who signed an open letter in support of Raicovich, it will require brave boards empowering their staff to see it through.



news

24-09-2018
Rassegna Stampa aggiornata al giorno 24 SETTEMBRE 2018

18-09-2018
Il Ministro Bonisoli: abolire la storia dell'arte

16-09-2018
Le mozioni dell'VIII Congresso Nazionale di Archeologia Medievale

14-09-2018
Manifesto della mostra sulle leggi razziali e il loro impatto in un liceo triestino.La censura del Comune

12-09-2018
Bando Premio Silvia Dell'orso: il 30 settembre scadono i termini per candidarsi

03-09-2018
Appello per la salvaguardia dellArchivio e del patrimonio culturale delle Acciaierie di Piombino

24-08-2018
A due anni dal terremoto in centro Italia

08-08-2018
Comitato per la Bellezza. Altro palazzone di 6 piani in piena riserva naturale del Litorale romano

24-07-2018
Da Emergenza Cultura: San Candido (BZ), uno sfregio che si poteva e doveva evitare

21-07-2018
Inchiesta de "L'Espresso" di Francesca Sironi: Il ministro Alberto Bonisoli e la scuola offshore

20-07-2018
Associazione Nazionale Archeologi. MIBAC: il titolo non è unopinione!

08-07-2018
Su Eddyburgh un intervento di Maria Pia Guermandi sull'Appia Antica

13-06-2018
Disponibile la relazione di Giuliano Volpe sull'attività del Consiglio Superiore

12-06-2018
Lettera aperta al Sig. Ministro dei Beni Culturali dott. Alberto Bonisoli: Per un futuro all'archeologia italiana

04-06-2018
Dalla rete: sul nuovo governo e sul nuovo ministro dei Beni culturali

19-05-2018
Sul contratto M5S - Lega vi segnaliamo...

17-05-2018
Cultura e Turismo: due punti della bozza Di Maio - Salvini

15-05-2018
Sulla Santa Bibiana di Bernini: intervento di Enzo Borsellino

13-05-2018
Premio Francovich 2018 per il miglior museo/parco archeologico relativo al periodo medievale

04-05-2018
Nella sezione "Interventi e recensioni" abbiamo pubblicato un contributo di Franco Pedrotti sul depuratore della piana di Pescasseroli: una sconfitta del protezionismo italiano

01-05-2018
Archistorie: rassegna di films sull'architettura dell'Associazione Silvia Dell'Orso

30-04-2018
Nella sezione "Interventi e recensioni", abbiamo pubblicato un contributo di Vittorio Emiliani: Appena 11 giardinieri per Villa Borghese. Ma l'erba "privata" non è meglio

26-04-2018
Roma. Il nuovo prato di piazza di Spagna non regge, il concorso ippico migra al Galoppatoio

21-04-2018
Anna Somers Cocks lascia The Art Newspaper. Intervista su "Il Giornale dell'Arte"

04-04-2018
VIII edizione del Premio Silvia Dell'Orso: il bando (scadenza 30/9/2018)

29-03-2018
Comitato per la Bellezza: A Palazzo Nardini chiedono già affitti altissimi ai negozi

25-03-2018
Lettera aperta di Archeologi Pubblico Impiego - MiBACT ai Soprintendenti ABAP

25-03-2018
A Foggia dal 5 aprile rassegna Dialoghi di Archeologia

23-03-2018
Comitato per la Bellezza e Osservatorio Roma: Tre richieste fondamentali per salvare Villa Borghese e Piazza di Siena

17-03-2018
Comunicato ANAI sul tema delle riproduzioni fotografiche libere

Archivio news