LEGGI
BENI IN PERICOLO
INTERVENTI E RECENSIONI
RASSEGNA STAMPA
COMUNICATI DELLE ASSOCIAZIONI
EVENTI
BIBLIOGRAFIA
STORIA e FORMAZIONE del CODICE DEI BENI CULTURALI E DEL PAESAGGIO
LINK
CHI SIAMO: REDAZIONE DI PATRIMONIOSOS
BACHECA DELLE TESI
per ricevere aggiornamenti sul sito inserisci il tuo indirizzo e-mail
patrimonio sos
in difesa dei beni culturali e ambientali

stampa Versione stampabile

Londra. Would the 'royal' Salvator Mundi please stand up?
MARTIN BAILEY
The Art Newspaper, 28/11/2018

Pushkin Museums Giampietrino painting may be the one listed in inventory of Charles Is collection, rather than the Abu Dhabi work




Fresh doubts are emerging over the English royal provenance of Leonardo da Vincis Salvator Mundi (dated around 1500), which was bought a year ago for Abu Dhabi. New evidence has revealed that another painting of the same subject, now in Moscows Pushkin State Museum of Fine Arts, is more likely to be the one recorded in the historic inventories.
Desmond Shawe-Taylor, the surveyor of the Queens Pictures at the Royal Collection, admits that it is far from certain that the recently sold Salvator Mundi is the one once owned by Englands kings. He tells The Art Newspaper: There are several references in inventories of the time of Charles I and Charles II to a Leonardo that might well be a Salvator Mundi, but it is unclear whether they refer to the painting recently sold by Christies, the one now attributed to Giampietrino in the Pushkin Museum or another, unidentified picture.
The Pushkins Salvator Mundi is on a panel that has a CR (Charles Rex) mark with a crown branded into the back of the poplar, which proves that it was once owned by Charles I. This evidence, which was overlooked when the Abu Dhabi picture was sold by Christies, was noted by Ben Lewis, who is writing a book, The Last Leonardo, due to be published by Harper Collins next April. He is convinced that the Pushkin painting raises serious doubts as to whether the Abu Dhabi picture is the one recorded in royal inventories.

Most of Charles Is art collection was sold off during the Civil War. In the 19th century, when the Russian Salvator Mundi was owned by the Moscow-based Mosolov family, it was attributed to Leonardo. The picture was acquired by the Pushkin in 1924 and is now regarded as being by Giampietrino, a Leonardo follower, and dated to sometime up to his death in 1549.
The royal provenance of the Abu Dhabi painting is much more problematic, since there is no CR branded into the reverse of the walnut panel. The back was apparently thinned and inserted into a cradle, most likely in the 19th century. Dianne Modestini, the restorer of the Abu Dhabi Salvator Mundi, says that the panel had been planed, probably in the 19th century, and this would have removed any collectors marks that might have been on the reverse.
Between 1649 and 1651, an inventory was compiled of the collection of Charles I, following his execution. There are two possible references to a Salvator Mundi by Leonardo. The first reads: A peece of Christ done by Leonardo at £30, Sold to Stone 23 Oct. 1651. Although the subject is not specified, it could well be a Salvator Mundi. The second reference is to A lords figure in halfe, £80, with an added note and Leonardo da Vinci, sold to Bass 19 Dec 1651. The lord is most likely to refer to Christ, and not to an aristocrat.
The Christies experts for the November 2017 sale were apparently only aware of the first reference and did not know about the Pushkin picture, so they linked their Salvator Mundi with the first referencethereby claiming that it had probably once been owned by Charles I. Indeed, in their catalogue, the chapter on provenance was entitled A peece of Christ done by Leonardo. When the picture entered Charles IIs collection, the inventory records a Leonardo da Vinci Christ with a globe in one hand and holding up the other.

The royal provenance suggested that its picture had been in the English royal collection in the first half of the 17th century, which bolstered the Leonardo attribution. This probably increased its perceived value, and it fetched a record $450m when it sold on 15 November 2017, going to a Gulf buyer.
Niko Munz, a specialist on the collection of Charles I, now believes that with this new evidence, it is likely that the peece of Christ refers to the Pushkin picture.
The Art Newspaper has already reported that Christies suggestion that the Abu Dhabi picture might have been owned earlier by the French royal family and brought to England by Henrietta Maria on her marriage in 1625 is also doubtful (September 2018, p1); there is now evidence that the picture could have been with the Duke of Hamilton.
Meanwhile, mystery surrounds the display of the Abu Dhabi picture. On 2 September, the emirates department of culture and tourism announced the postponement of the works unveiling at Louvre Abu Dhabi, promising that more details will be announced soon. There was speculation that this might take place on the first anniversary of the opening of Louvre Abu Dhabi on 11 November, but no news was released.
It remains unclear whether the delay is over payment or ownership issues, or over conservation or attributional issues. The Louvre in Paris is presumably hoping to display the painting in its major Leonardo show, due to open in autumn 2019, but this remains unconfirmed.

https://www.theartnewspaper.com/news/would-the-royal-salvator-mundi-please-stand-up


news

18-09-2020
RASSEGNA STAMPA aggiornata al giorno 18 settembre 2020

03-09-2020
Storia dell'arte cancellata, lo strano caso di un dramma inesistente, di Andrea Ragazzini

27-07-2020
Il Consiglio Direttivo dell'Associazione Italiana di Studi Bizantini su Santa Sofia

06-06-2020
Sicilia. Appello di docenti, esperti e storici dell'arte all'Ars: "Ritirate il ddl di riforma dei Beni culturali"

06-05-2020
Due articoli da "Mi riconosci? sono un professionista dei beni culturali"

05-05-2020
Confiscabile il bene culturale detenuto allestero anche se in presunta buona fede

30-04-2020
In margine a un intervento di Vincenzo Trione sul distanziamento nei musei

26-04-2020
Vi segnaliamo: Il caso del Sacramentario di Frontale: commento alla sentenza della Corte di Cassazione

25-04-2020
Turismo di prossimità, strada possibile per conoscere il nostro patrimonio

24-04-2020
Un programma per la cultura: un documento per la ripresa

22-04-2020
Il 18 maggio per la Giornata internazionale dei musei notizie dall'ICOM

15-04-2020
Inchiesta: Cultura e lavoro ai tempi di COVID-19

15-04-2020
Museums will move on: message from ICOM President Suay Aksoy

08-04-2020
Al via il progetto di formazione a distanza per il personale MiBACT e per i professionisti della cultura

06-04-2020
Lettera - mozione in vista della riunione dell'Eurogruppo del 7 aprile - ADESIONI

30-03-2020
Da "Finestre sull'arte" intervista a Eike Schmidt

30-03-2020
I danni del terremoto ai musei di Zagabria

29-03-2020
Le iniziative digitali dei musei, siti archeologici, biblioteche, archivi, teatri, cinema e musica.

21-03-2020
Comunicato della Consulta di Topografia Antica sulla tutela degli archeologi nei cantieri

16-03-2020
Lombardia: emergenza Covid-19. Lettera dell'API (Archeologi del Pubblico Impiego)

12-03-2020
Arte al tempo del COVID-19. Fra le varie iniziative online vi segnaliamo...

06-03-2020
Sul Giornale dell'Arte vi segnaliamo...

06-02-2020
I musei incassano, i lavoratori restano precari: la protesta dei Cobas

31-01-2020
Nona edizione di Visioni d'Arte, rassegna promossa dall'Associazione Silvia Dell'Orso

06-01-2020
Da Finestre sull'arte: Trump minaccia di colpire 52 obiettivi in Iran, tra cui siti culturali. Ma attaccare la cultura è crimine di guerra

06-01-2020
Dalla stampa estera di ieri: minacce di Trump contro siti culturali iraniani

20-12-2019
Riorganizzazione Mibact, Casini: non è ennesimo Lego, ma manutenzione amministrativa in continuità

04-12-2019
Libero riuso delle riproduzioni di beni culturali: articolo di Daniele Manacorda sul "Giornale dell'arte"

14-11-2019
Cosa succederà alla Biblioteca Guarneriana di S. Daniele del Friuli? Un appello dei cittadini al sindaco

04-10-2019
Unicredit mette all'asta da Christie's capolavori della sua collezione

Archivio news